Исполнение постановлений ЕСПЧ: последние решения Комитета министров Совета Европы
Комитет министров Совета Европы опубликовал последние отдельные решения, касающиеся исполнения постановлений Европейского суда по правам человека.
По окончании своего ежеквартального заседания по правам человека в Страсбурге Комитет принял 26 решений относительно 17 государств-членов.
Заключительные резолюции были приняты Комитетом в отношении 541 постановления и решения Страсбургского суда, касающегося 18 стран.
Комитет также принял ориентировочный перечень дел, которые будут рассмотрены на его следующем заседании, посвященном исполнению постановлений, которое состоится в декабре 2018 года.
No. | Case | State | Application | Judgment final on | Violation | Last examination (decision) |
1 | LULI AND OTHERS GROUP | ALBANIA | 64480/09+ | 01/07/2014 | Excessive length of civil proceedings and absence of a remedy in that respect. | December 2016 |
2 | ILGAR MAMMADOV (individual situation of the applicant) | AZERBAIJAN | 15172/13 | 13/10/2014 | Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicant for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5. | December 2017 |
3 | TRABELSI | BELGIUM | 140/10 | 16/02/2015 | Extradition of the applicant to the USA, where he risks an irreducible life sentence; non-respect of interim measure indicated by the Court | December 2017 |
4 | BELL | BELGIUM | 44826/05+ | 06/04/2009 | Excessive length of civil and/or criminal proceedings | December 2015 |
5 | KUNIĆ AND OTHERS GROUP | BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA | 68955/12+ | 14/02/2018 | Non-enforcement of final judgments ordering the payment of work-related benefits. | First examination |
6 | NENCHEVA AND OTHERS | BULGARIA | 48609/06 | 18/09/2013 | Lack of prompt and sufficient measures to prevent deaths of children placed in public care; lack of prompt and effective investigation into these deaths. | December 2016 |
7 | UNITED MACEDONIAN ORGANISATION ILINDEN AND OTHERS GROUP | BULGARIA | 59491/00 | 19/04/2006 | Unjustified refusals by the courts to register an association aiming at achieving “the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria”. | June 2018 |
8 | STATILEO GROUP | CROATIA | 12027/10 | 10/10/2014 | Statutory limitations on use of property by landlords, including through the rent control scheme for flats subject to protected leases. | September 2017 |
9 | M.A. GROUP | CYPRUS | 41872/10 | 23/10/2013 | Lack of effective remedy with automatic suspensive effect in deportation proceedings and absence of speedy review of lawfulness of detention. | June 2017 |
10 | MERABISHVILI | GEORGIA | 72508/13 | 28/11/2017 | Failure by the domestic courts to give relevant and sufficient reasons to justify continuation of detention on remand; continued detention on remand with the predominant purpose of obtaining information from the applicant about third persons. | First examination |
11 | BEKA-KOULOCHERI GROUP | GREECE | 38878/03 | 06/10/2006 | Non-compliance by the authorities with domestic court decisions and lack of an effective remedy. | September 2017 |
12 | BEKIR OUSTA GROUP | GREECE | 35151/05 | 11/01/2008 | Refusal of domestic courts to register the applicants’ associations. | December 2017 |
13 | MAKARATZIS GROUP | GREECE | 50385/99 | 20/12/2004 | Ill-treatment by coastguards and other state agents and lack of effective investigations. | December 2017 |
14 | GAZSÓ GROUP | HUNGARY | 48322/12 | 16/10/2015 | Excessive length of judicial proceedings and lack of an effective remedy in this respect. | March 2018 |
15 | PAKSAS | LITHUANIA | 34932/04 | 06/01/2011 | Permanent and irreversible ban on standing for parliamentary elections due to the applicant’s removal from presidential office following impeachment proceedings. | March 2018 |
16 | CORSACOV GROUP LEVINTA | REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA | 18944/02 17332/03 | 04/07/2006 16/03/2009 | Ill-treatment and torture in police custody; ineffective investigations; lack of an effective remedy. Conviction based on evidence obtained under torture. | December 2016 |
17 | TARABURCA GROUP | REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA | 18919/10 | 06/03/2012 | Ill-treatment by the police in connection with violent demonstrations and ineffective investigation thereof; lack of effective civil remedies to claim compensation for the ill-treatment. | June 2016 |
18 | BĄK GROUP | POLAND | 7870/04 | 16/04/2007 | Excessive length of criminal proceedings and lack of an effective remedy. | December 2017 |
19 | BELLER GROUP | POLAND | 51837/99 | 06/06/2005 | Excessive length of proceedings before administrative bodies and courts; lack of an effective remedy. | December 2016 |
20 | MAJEWSKI GROUP RUTKOWSKI AND OTHERS Jan ZAŁUSKA, Marianna ROGALSKA AND 398 OTHER APPLICATIONS | POLAND | 52690/99 72287/10 53491/10+ | 11/01/2006 07/10/2015 20/06/2017 | Excessive length of civil proceedings and lack of an effective remedy. | December 2017 |
21 | VICENTE CARDOSO GROUP | PORTUGAL | 30130/10 | 12/03/2013 | Excessive length of judicial proceedings. | June 2016 |
22 | CENTRE FOR LEGAL RESOURCES ON BEHALF OF VALENTIN CÂMPEANU | ROMANIA | 47848/08 | 17/07/2014 | Deficiencies in the legal protection and medical and social care afforded to vulnerable persons. | December 2017 |
23 | N. | ROMANIA | 59152/08 | 28/02/2018 | Unlawful psychiatric confinement as a security measure and deficiencies in the judicial review proceedings regarding the applicant’s continued confinement. | First examination |
24 | REZMIVEŞ AND OTHERS + BRAGADIREANU GROUP | ROMANIA | 61467/12+ 22088/04 | 25/07/2017 06/03/2008 | Overcrowding and poor conditions of detention in prisons and police detention facilities; lack of an effective remedy in that regard; inadequacy of medical care and several other dysfunctions regarding the protection of prisoners’ rights. | March 2018 |
25 | ALEKSEYEV / BAYEV AND OTHERS | RUSSIAN FEDERATION | 4916/07 / 67667/09 | 11/04/2011 / 13/11/2017 | Repeated bans on the holding of LGBTI persons’ marches and pickets; lack of effective remedies; discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation in the exercise of the right to freedom of peaceful assembly. Fines imposed on the applicants for displaying banners considered to promote homosexuality among minors against the laws prohibiting such “propaganda”. | Alekseyev: CM/Del/Dec(2016)1273/H46-23 December 2016 Bayev: first examination |
26 | KUDESHKINA | RUSSIAN FEDERATION | 29492/05 | 14/09/2009 | Dismissal from judicial office for making critical media statements about the judiciary | March 2018 |
27 | LIU No. 2 GROUP | RUSSIAN FEDERATION | 29157/09 | 08/03/2012 | Refusal to grant residence permit based on national security considerations and administrative removal in breach of the right to family life. | March 2013 |
28 | ZORICA JOVANOVIĆ | SERBIA | 21794/08 | 09/09/2013 | Failure to provide information as to the fate of new-born babies alleged to have died in maternity wards. | June 2018 |
29 | CYPRUS v. TURKEY | TURKEY | 25781/94 | 10/05/2001 12/05/2014 | 14 violations in relation to the situation in the northern part of Cyprus (property rights of the enclaved). | March 2018 |
30 | OPUZ GROUP | TURKEY | 33401/02 | 09/09/2009 | Failure to provide protection from domestic violence. | |
31 | VARNAVA AND OTHERS | TURKEY | 16064/90+ | 18/09/2009 | Lack of effective investigation into the fate of nine Greek Cypriots who disappeared during the military operations undertaken by Turkey in Cyprus in 1974. | September 2018 |
32 | XENIDES-ARESTIS GROUP | TURKEY | 46347/99 | 22/03/2006 23/05/2007 | Continuous denial of access to property in the northern part of Cyprus. | September 2018 |
No. | Case | State | Application | Judgment final on | Violation | Last examination (decision) |
33 | KEBE AND OTHERS | UKRAINE | 12552/12 | 12/04/2017 | Lack of adequate safeguards in the border-control procedure to protect from arbitrary removal and lack of effective remedy. | First examination |
34 | NEVMERZHITSKY,YAKOVENKO, LOGVINENKO, ISAYEV and MELNIK GROUPS | UKRAINE | 54825/00 | 12/10/2005 | Poor conditions of detention and lack of adequate medical treatment. | March 2018 |
35 | YURIY NIKOLAYEVICH IVANOV + ZHOVNER GROUP BURMYCH AND OTHERS | UKRAINE | 40450/04 56848/00 46852/13 | 15/01/2010 29/09/2004 12/10/2017 | Non-enforcement of domestic court decisions against the State or state-owned enterprises. | June 2018 |
Государства-члены Совета Европы обязаны исполнять постановления Европейского суда по правам человека в соответствии со статьей 46 Конвенции о правах человека.
Комитет министров осуществляет надзор за исполнением постановлений на основе информации, предоставляемой соответствующими национальными властями, НПО и другими заинтересованными сторонами.
- Веб-сайт Департамента по вопросам исполнения постановлений
- Видеоматериал о надзорном процессе
- Инфографика: количество закрытых дел на сегодняшний день в процентном отношении
Контактное лицо: Эндрю Каттинг, пресс-секретарь/пресс-атташе, тел. +32 485 217 202
Twitter: @coe_execution #CMDH1324
Бажаєте бути в курсі найважливіших подій? Підписуйтесь на АНТИРЕЙД у соцмережах.
Обирайте, що вам зручніше:
- Телеграм t.me/antiraid
- Фейсбук facebook.com/antiraid
- Твіттер twitter.com/antiraid
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!